Hire Editorial Managers With a Structured Scorecard
Define the work, required evidence, and interview criteria before sourcing Editorial Manager candidates. This guide turns the role into a consistent, auditable hiring process.
Define the publication or content operation this manager runs: its audience, formats, contributors, and publishing rhythm. Then look for editorial judgment under pressure. The decisive evidence is how they built or enforced a style guide, handled a difficult contributor, and kept quality up while meeting deadlines, including how they incorporate search needs without weakening the writing.
Editorial managers run content operations: calendars, contributors, standards, and publication. Roles range from a blog with a few freelancers to a multi-channel team with editors and AI-assisted workflows. Your volume, review needs, and team shape determine the right profile. Use this guide to scope the job and compare candidates on the same editorial tasks.
What Editorial Managers do day to day
The core work of the role, before tools and titles. Check that your brief, your interviews, and your scorecard all cover it.
Run the editorial calendar and content production
Edit for quality, accuracy, and voice
Manage writers and freelancers
Set editorial standards and processes
Skills to look for in Editorial Managers
Group requirements by area so the job post, the interview plan, and the scorecard test the same things.
01
Editing
Structure, clarity, and fact-checking.
02
Management
Writers, workflows, and deadlines.
03
Strategy
Editorial planning and audience focus.
Which specialization do you need?
Most Editorial Managers lean toward one of these. Name the one you need in the brief instead of listing every tool.
Content marketing
Brand editorial programs.
Publishing
Media and publications.
SEO editorial
Search-driven content.
Editorial role levels and evaluation evidence
Adjust the scope to the actual job. Seniority should reflect decision ownership and the complexity of the work, not years alone.
1
Junior
Typical scope
Entry-level profile with a strong foundation in content editing, style guide adherence, and basic CMS operations.
Knowledge areas
WordPressGoogle DocsAP StyleAsana
What to look for
Hands-on experience managing editorial calendars and coordinating with freelance contributors. Familiarity with CMS platforms such as WordPress, Contentful, or Webflow.
2
Mid
Typical scope
Mid-level profile with proven expertise in cross-functional team coordination, SEO content optimization, and brand voice development.
Knowledge areas
ContentfulSEMrushAhrefsNotion
What to look for
Demonstrated ability to develop and enforce comprehensive style guides across distributed teams. Experience integrating SEO requirements into editorial workflows without compromising narrative quality.
3
Senior
Typical scope
Senior profile with deep mastery of publication strategy, stakeholder management, and scalable content operations architecture.
Knowledge areas
WebflowClearscopeJiraFigma
What to look for
Proven track record leading editorial teams through high-volume publication cycles across multiple channels. Experience implementing AI-assisted content workflows while maintaining brand integrity and quality standards.
What should an Editorial Manager role brief include?
Describe the audiences, formats, and channels, the size of the contributor pool, and the content management system in use. Say who approves topics and who gives final sign-off. Explain how search requirements and subject experts fit in. Make editing quality, process design, and feedback skill must-haves. Familiarity with your CMS is learnable.
Audiences, formats, channels, and expected publishing rhythm
Contributor mix: staff, freelancers, subject experts, and agencies
Style guide status and who owns updates to it
Fact-checking, legal review, and final approval steps
How should Editorial Manager candidates be compared?
Give each candidate the same flawed draft and a style excerpt and ask for an edit with written feedback to the author. Add a scheduling scenario with conflicting deadlines. Strong evidence includes precise edits, constructive feedback, realistic prioritization, and respect for both reader needs and search requirements.
Hand over one flawed draft and request an edit plus author feedback
Provide a calendar conflict and ask how they would reprioritize
Ask to see a style guide section they wrote and an example of enforcing it
Check how they handle a contributor who disputes edits
What to probe when interviewing Editorial Manager candidates
These are risks a weak hire in this role tends to bring. Turn each into a work-sample task or follow-up question that produces evidence for or against it, and score every candidate on the same set.
Can they develop a style guide that scales across a 15-person distributed content team, or do they just enforce AP Style basics?
Have they successfully integrated SEO requirements into editorial workflows without sacrificing narrative quality?
Do they know how to manage sensitive author feedback while hitting aggressive publication deadlines?
Job description template
A starting draft built from this guide. Replace the bracketed parts, cut anything that does not apply, and keep every requirement tied to the work.
Job description template
About the role
[Two or three sentences on the product, the team, and why this role is open now.]
What you will do
Run the editorial calendar and content production
Edit for quality, accuracy, and voice
Manage writers and freelancers
Set editorial standards and processes
What you bring
Editing: Structure, clarity, and fact-checking.
Management: Writers, workflows, and deadlines.
Strategy: Editorial planning and audience focus.
Nice to have
Content marketing
Publishing
SEO editorial
Level and scope
Junior: Entry-level profile with a strong foundation in content editing, style guide adherence, and basic CMS operations.
Mid: Mid-level profile with proven expertise in cross-functional team coordination, SEO content optimization, and brand voice development.
Senior: Senior profile with deep mastery of publication strategy, stakeholder management, and scalable content operations architecture.
How we hire
A structured interview and a short work sample, scored against the same criteria for every candidate.
Full-time, contract, or freelance?
Editorial management is usually full-time, because it coordinates ongoing production. A contractor suits setting up a process. Ask for an editorial system they built.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions About Hiring Editorial Managers
Direct answers for role definition, evaluation, specialist depth, and compensation research.
What does an editorial manager do?
An editorial manager runs the content calendar and the people and process behind it. They assign topics, edit or oversee editing, maintain the style guide, coordinate contributors, and ensure content is published on time and meets quality standards. They also work with search, design, and social teams. In some companies they set content strategy as well.
Which skills should I evaluate in an editorial manager?
Evaluate line and structural editing, style guide development, project management, and feedback skills. Familiarity with search requirements and a content management system matters. Seniors should show publication strategy, stakeholder management, and workflows that scale across channels, including responsible handling of AI-assisted drafts and brand integrity checks.
How can I assess an editorial manager candidate?
Use identical editing and scheduling exercises for each candidate, then a conversation about a content operation they ran. Ask about volume, contributors, standards, and what they changed. Score editing precision, feedback tone, process thinking, and fit with your approval structure. Ask contributors in their references how the candidate gave feedback.
Editorial manager, content strategist, or managing editor?
A content strategist decides what to publish and why. An editorial manager runs the people and process that produce it. A managing editor often handles day-to-day scheduling and production for a publication. In smaller companies one person covers all three. Hire for the gap you have: direction, operations, or quality control.
What affects compensation for editorial managers?
Pay follows seniority, size of contributor network, content volume, and scope across channels. Publishing, software, and regulated industries structure roles differently. Collect current listings and survey data from your local market for comparable editorial managers, keeping the source and collection date next to every number. Set the range only after matching responsibilities, not labels. Decide whether the role includes strategy or only operations before setting a range.
ConnectDevs can support discovery and structured interview workflows, but the hiring team remains responsible for the role definition, evidence standard, final decision, compensation validation, and applicable legal review.